Charity Lawyers
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Who we are
    • Our team
  • Expertise
    • At a glance
    • In depth
      • Tax & duties
      • Governance
      • Charitable Trusts
      • Structures: establishment & restructuring
      • Mergers, collaborations & strategic alliances
      • Gifts, charitable fundraising & promotions
      • Disputes & regulatory reviews
      • Workplace & People issues
      • Brand, information & reputation protection
      • Property
  • Insights
    • At a glance
    • View articles
      • Updated transparency requirements under the Commonwealth Electoral Act
      • Pastoral care services DGR category
      • Resignation of director notification
      • Permanent changes to the Corporations Act regarding meetings and documents to come into force
      • Global Alliance of Impact Lawyers Launch Week
      • Prolegis Lawyers ranked Band 1 by Chambers
      • Recent changes to the Corporations Act for electronic meetings, notices, minute books and e-signing due to the Covid-19 pandemic
      • Recent decisions in Australian charity law – update
      • New requirements for DGRs to be registered as charities with the ACNC
      • High Court rules on who is a Casual employee
      • Streamlining of regulation of charities undertaking fundraising in NSW
      • Changes to Charities’ Financial Reporting Obligations
      • Changes to Casual Employment
      • Women’s Life Centre – A recent decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal regarding Public Benevolent Institutions (PBIs)
      • Final Report of the 2020 Review of Disability Standards for Education 2005
      • Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety - final report released
      • UPDATE 25 February 2021: Introducing ACNC Governance Standard 6 and changes to Basic Religious Charity eligibility
      • Treasury Consultation: Proposed changes to ACNC Governance Standard 3
      • Breaking: Charities to lose charitable status if they fail to join the National Redress Scheme
      • New Bill – Requiring DGRs to Register as Charities
      • Federal Budget 2020-21
      • NZ High Court finds Greenpeace NZ should be registered as a charity
      • A member of a charity has a fiduciary duty to act in the best interest of the charity?
      • Key Changes- incorporated associations in Queensland
      • Bill for new DGR category for Community Sheds now law
      • UPDATE 2 June 2020: SME Commercial Leasing Principles During COVID-19 - what does it mean for charities and not-for-profits?
      • UPDATE 19 May 2020: COVID-19 – Information for Charities and Not-for-Profits
      • UPDATE 6 May 2020: COVID-19 - Ancillary Funds, Disaster Relief Funds and AGM for companies
      • Draft bill for new DGR Category: Men’s and Women’s Sheds
      • An Update: COVID-19 Australian government’s economic response – What’s for charities and not-for-profits?
      • COVID-19 Australian government’s economic response – What’s for charities and not-for-profits?
      • ACNC to review registered charities beginning with Public Benevolent Institutions in July 2020
      • Government response to the recommendations of the ACNC Legislation Review
      • Fundraising– considerations for charities, fundraisers and donors
      • Minute-taking post Banking Royal Commission
      • Taxation Ruling: 'in Australia' conditions
      • Key changes to the Victorian Fundraising Act
      • Religious Discrimination Bill- Update
      • New protections for whistleblowers – what does it mean for charities and not-for-profits? UPDATE
      • Significant Changes in Payment and Record Keeping Requirements for Clerical and Administrative Staff
      • New Tax Office Ruling - Fringe Benefits Provided to Religious Practitioners
      • ACNC External Conduct Standards - Update
      • Fair Work Australia decision will introduce changes in entitlements and record keeping requirements of clerical and administrative employees
      • Royal Commission into Violence, Abuse, Neglect and Exploitation of People with Disability
      • National Redress Scheme Update
      • DGR reform proposals
      • Release of the ACNC Review Report
      • Not So Casual
      • ACNC External Conduct Standards - Public Consultation
      • Law on Advocacy by Charities
      • New ATO Draft Ruling on the fringe benefits tax: benefits provided to religious practitioners
      • Employment update - New numbers for key employment issues for a new tax year
      • Electoral disclosure & funding reform: why charities and NFPs should be concerned
      • Review of ACNC Framework
      • Reforming Administration of Tax Deductible Gift Recipients - a victory for common sense?
      • Righting Wrongs: Victoria takes lead on organisational child abuse legislation
      • Tax Deductible Gift Recipient Reform Opportunities
      • When may a charity board member be paid for their services?
      • #fixfundraising
      • Privacy Law Update: Mandatory Data Breach Notifications to come into force by the end of 2017
      • Good Things Come To Those Who Wait? ACNC releases Commissioner’s Interpretation Statement on Public Benevolent Institutions
      • Privacy Obligations - Lessons and reminders from the Red Cross Data Breach
      • Charities and the Australian Consumer Law - reducing duplication and confusion
  • Careers
  • Contact

Get In Touch


Sydney

Level 4, 107 Mount Street
North Sydney NSW 2060
Australia

   +61 2 9466 5222

  info@prolegis.com.au

Melbourne

Suite 5
197 Springvale Road
Nunawading VIC 3131
Australia

   +61 3 8672 2920

  info@prolegis.com.au

Insights

Minute-taking post Banking Royal Commission

   February 2020   |  Insights   |  Seak-King Huang and Tina Lee

The Financial Services (Banking) Royal Commission, among many other aspects of good corporate governance, put the practice of minute-taking under a spotlight and, in particular, how detailed should board minutes be.


Since we published this article, the Australian Institute of Company Directors has published their updated guide to board minutes.   This updated guide, which is one of the AICD’s excellent “Directors Tools” series, is available here

What does the law require? The law offers no further guidance than that the “proceedings and resolutions” of company directors’ meetings are to be recorded within one month of the meeting.

For registered charities, the Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission (ACNC) offers a template for the format of minutes, but does not offer further guidance as to how charities should prepare minutes. The relevant section in the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) that governs minute-taking (section 251A) is switched off for companies that are registered charities, and so it would be necessary to carefully consult your charity’s constitution to determine whether these provisions have been switched back on and whether the constitution imposes any specific requirements on your charity in respect of meetings and minute-taking. Regardless, it is important to remember that a charity’s responsible persons - meaning its directors - still have certain duties under the ACNC governance standards. Generally, the duties mean that responsible persons should act with care and diligence and in good faith in the charity’s best interests – this would naturally extend to the holding and conduct of meetings and minute-taking.

When it comes to preparing board minutes, there is no ‘one size fits all’ approach. Board minutes are a record of board decisions and the process by which those decisions were made. They are not a transcript, or even a report, of the discussion or debate during the meeting. There is an art to finding the right balance between reporting outcomes of board meetings and recording discussion. While there is no expectation that the minutes record verbatim what was discussed at a board meeting, it is expected that those minutes capture, and therefor are the evidence of, the matters that were discussed in the meeting.

In the context of the Royal Commission, the question raised was: if a director says something happened, but it is not shown in the minutes, does that leave the board exposed? It may not be surprising that the legal answer is both ‘yes’ and ‘no’. As official company records of board meetings, courts place evidentiary weight on the contents of minutes. If the minutes do not record that a particular thing happened, it becomes difficult for a director to assert that it did because a key source of evidence is silent about it.

Post-Royal Commission, it is not sufficient that the board minutes record only the resolutions or “headlines” of what was discussed – it is also imperative that they include

  • some detail on how those resolutions were arrived at;
  • the key points of discussion;
  • questions raised;
  • and the broad reasons for decisions.

Board minutes should also note where and why directors questioned management, sought clarification and asked for more information.

The Joint Statement on board minutes published by the Australian Institute of Company Directors and the Governance Institute of Australia in August 2019 is a helpful resource for directors and company secretaries.  But in a nutshell, there are three relevant factors to consider when preparing minutes and the level of detail required:

·        the nature and importance of, and the risk attaching to, the decision and discussion concerned;

·        the regulatory environment that either the organisation generally, or the particular decision, is subject to; and

·        any perceived self-interest or conflict of interest on the part of the board or management.

If you require specific advice, please contact Seak-King Huang (shuang@prolegis.com.au) or Tina Lee (tlee@prolegis.com.au).  We regularly advise on many different aspects of corporate governance.

We are grateful for the assistance of Lara Emery in the preparation of this article

Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.





Quick Links

⇢    Our Team
⇢    About Us
⇢    Expertise
⇢    Insights
⇢    ACNC

Latest News

  • March 2022
    Updated transparency requirements under the Commonwealth Electoral Act
  • March 2022
    Pastoral care services DGR category
  • March 2022
    Resignation of director notification
  • March 2022
    Permanent changes to the Corporations Act regarding meetings and documents to come into force
  • February 2022
    Global Alliance of Impact Lawyers Launch Week

Latest News & Insights

  • Updated transparency requirements under the Commonwealth Electoral Act March 2022
  • Pastoral care services DGR category March 2022
  • Resignation of director notification March 2022

Useful Links

  • Our Team
  • About Us
  • Expertise
  • Insights
  • ACNC

Sydney Office

Level 4, 107 Mount Street
North Sydney  NSW   2060
Australia

+61 2 9466 5222

info@prolegis.com.au

Melbourne Office

Suite 5

197 Springvale Road
Nunawading  VIC  3131
Australia

+61 3 8672 2920

info@prolegis.com.au

Copyright © Prolegis Lawyers. All Rights Reserved.

  • Privacy Policy